Материал: Трубецкой Е.Н.. Философия права профессора Л. И. Петражицкого
~ '"='.. ...- ~ ; |
' |
12 |
u |
... |
RH. EBrEHIH TPYEEqKOH. |
||
,MarasHHa, Bn KOTopoM» MIJ XOTMM» KyrrHTh HYJKHYIO .llJUI Hac'bBem~>, aama aoJIH HHq-fnvln He cB.R3aHa: MDI BDI6npaeMn TOn o6pas'blliii1-
cTBii1, KOTOpi:J::H npe.n.cTaBJIHeTC.R HaM-:D HaH6oJI-Ee rrpinTHhiM':DH u-EJie..
cooopa3HDIM':D. «B-:D JlpyrHX'b CJiylJaEX'b, Mhl, HanpOTMBb, tJYBCTByeM~
C~Jl3a1-I:HOCmb HauteU 60Jl.U, ll)'BCTByeM':DHe06XO.llHMOCTl> I10CTYI1HTb
TaK':D HJIH HHalle |
aesaBHCHMO OT':D coo6pa»<eHi:H yli.OBO.JihCTBi.H H aro~ |
||||||
HCTHlJeCKOM |
l10Jlh3N. <<KaKOH-TO |
BHyTpeHHiH rOJLOC':D aBTOpHTeTHO |
|||||
rrpe.zr.rrHChlBaeT-:D, |
rrpellonpell.iiJrneT'b Harne rrose.n;eHie; Harna coBi>CTh |
||||||
«llOBeJI-£BaeT-:D» |
Ha.M'b TO |
HJIH 11pyroe; MHI:J:.MH |
CJIOBa.MH, HaM'h npH- |
||||
cyiUM TaKiJI |
y6ir>K.lleHiH, |
l{OTOphl.H |
BJiaCTHO li aBT-OpHTeTHO JlJI.H HaC'b |
||||
me |
taMHX'b"ifopMHpyiOT'b Hame ITOBeJJ.eHie». 9THM'bITOBeJIHTeJihHhiM"b |
||||||
HOpMaM'b, yrrpaBJUIIOIUH.M'b Hameiii |
COBiCThiO, Ml>I npHilliChiBaeM'bBNC- |
||||||
. |
, |
|
.... |
|
|
. |
|
III1H aBTOpHTeT':D·He |
TOJih}{O DO OTHOilJeHliO K':D Ha.M'b ca.Mli:M'b, HO H |
||||||
DO |
QTHOIIIeHiiO K'b .1IpyrHM'b JII0.1IHM'b: Mhl y6inK,lleHIJ B'b 1'0M'b,llTO |
||||||
He |
Mbl Oli.HH, HO |
H |
BC.HKiH Ha HameM"b .M-JicTi |
,ZLOJI»<eH':D 6h1JI'b 6IJ |
|||
ITOCTYITHTI:. TaKn, 1\a-K'h I10.llCKa3L1BaeT'b Ha.M'bBHyTpeHHiH roJIOC'bHameR COB-JiCTH.
«0TMi>tzeHHOe BI:J:llie llYBCTBO CBH3aHHOCTH Hallie~ BOJJH,-I1pOli.OJI- Jl(aeT'b r. TieTpamHUI{iH,-C03HaHie H.eo6XO.llM.MQCTM I10ll.lJHHeHfH eH M3Bi>CTHOMY aBTOpHTeTHOMY HMDYJI~>cy (asTopMTeTHOMY no6y}K.ll.eHiro
.K"b Ta.KOMY HJIH HHOMY DOBe,ll.eHiro) MI>I Bbipa}KaeM-:D CJIOBaMH: 06.H- 3aHHOCTh, 1l0Jit.I:., o6.R3aTeJihCTBO, li.OJI:>KeHCTBOBaRie, a rl yoi>»<.l(e- Hiil, KOTOpbiH nopOJK.llaiOT'b T.aldE HJIH HHbUI o6.R3aHHOCTH, T. e. aBTOpHTeTHO peryJIHpyiOT'b Hallie llOBelleHie (aBTOpHTe'J:'HO-HMITYJih-~
CHBHDIH yM:>K.lleHiH) .MIJ Ha3I:J:Bae.M'b HOpMaMH, Hl'vUiepaTHBaMH».
~l..JyBCTBO CBJI3aHH0CTM Hairrefi BOJIH 6DIBaeT':D B"b pa3JJHllHbiX'bCJJy-
lJa.HX'b JKM3H~ pa3.lilflJHh1.M'b, a COOTBi>TCTBeHHO C"b 3TliM'b- HeO.zr.H-
Ha.KOBa DplipOJla Ti>X'bDOBeJIHTeJII:.HI:J:X'bHOpM'b,KOTOp,bi.H ynpaBJI.HlOT'b
HalliMM'b nose..n.eHie~'b. |
Hallie ITCHXMlJeCKOe OTHOIIIeHie K'b 6i>.ztHHKY- |
|||||||
MsaHy, |
I{OTopoMy |
MI:.l |
CllliTaeM'b ceoJI o6.R3aHH1>IMH 1{aTh JI.eC.HTh py6- |
|||||
Jieiii no |
.ll.OJiry |
lJeJIOBrBKOJII06in, COBCi;M'b He Tal{OBO, Kai<"':. Harne I1CH- |
||||||
XHlJeCI{Oe |
OTHorneHie K':DM3B03lJHKY IIeTpy, KOTopoMy MI:J: o6ssaJIMCh |
|||||||
ynJJaTH:Th |
.l[eC.RTh py6Jieii |
a a cosepmeHHYIO HM» c-:D |
1-iaMH no-E3.zr.Ky. |
|||||
«lfBaHy |
Mbi HHqero He |
.l(OJI}I(HJ,I; ezv1y HH'llero OT'b |
HaC':D He <CCJii- |
|||||
.11yeT'b>> 7 |
He « npHllHTaeTCH»; eCJlH OH"J, nOJIYllMT'b I 0 py6Jieif, TO 3TO- |
|||||||
.lli>JIO Har.qeH: «.n:oopo H: |
BOJIM». HecMoTpn Ha cm13aHHOCTh |
Halliy no |
||||||
OTHOIIIeairo Kn |
coocTBei:IHhlM'b y6-EJK.zr.eaiHM-:D, K'b Haiiieli- « coa icTM», |
|||||||
no omHomeuiro |
«'b |
HBaay |
MI:J: cqHaaeM-:D ce6H cBo6oi}Hbt.M,u, |
He cBR3aH- |
||||
llhlM11 H |
OT':D Hero |
omH.ZI.aeM-:D npnsHaHiH aToif csooop:hl, |
rrpHsiiaHiR |
|||||
~HJIOOOmiH ITPABA ITPO~ECCOP..A. Jr. 1. ttETPAmHttk.At'O. |
13 |
||
HailleM <<.LJ.06poi1: BOJIH», .ZI.3.Th HJIH |
He .n.aTh, a BO BCRKOM'b |
CJITiai> |
|
He O>KHJiaeM» nporRBonoJio:mHaro |
OTHorueHi.H». |
EcJIH 6u |
HBaH'b |
cTaJI'b Tpe6oaaTh C"b Hac'L ynJial'hl 10 py6Jie:H, |
KaK'b qero-To eMy |
||
ll:OJI}I(Haro, TO, oqeBH,l.{HO, l\1LI TaKOe TpeOOBaHie COlJJIH 6hl . «He-
yMi>CTHhHY1'b, HaxaJihHblMn ». |
C.noBOM'b, Hama HpaacTBeHHaH o6H3aH- |
|
HOCTb-.ZI.aTh Io py6Jie:H |
ue |
3au.pnnAeua aa HBartoM?J: «M:bl ':IYBCTayeM» |
IIO OTHOilleHiiO K'blifMY |
CB060.Ziy OTBepHyTh OT'bHero ROJIO}J{MTeJib- |
|
HblM nOJliOC'b Hamero HaMipeHi.H, Harrp. ,HanpaBHTh ero Ha .ll.pyroro,
6oJiie Hym,naromarocH».
« Coaci>M'b HHOe, npHMO rrpoTHBOnoJiomHoe roaopHT'b :aaM'bHarne
C03HaHie |
0 |
HallJeM'b OTHOilleHiH K'b lleTpy, KOTOpbiM |
3a paOOTaJI'b C'b |
|||||
HaC.b 10 |
py6JieM, |
,li.OCTaB"HB'b HaC"b B'b ropOJI'b, MJIH t<OTOpOMY |
Mol |
|||||
rlpoHrpaJIH |
ro |
py6JieH. EMy MlJ .LJ.OJOKHhl 1o RY6Jie:H, eMy cni>.n:yeT'IJ, |
||||||
npHllHTaeTc.H |
OT£> |
Hac'b no.nylll:fTh to |
py6Jiei1:. |
Do |
OTROilleHiro |
K'b |
||
I - |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
'J-lelrt1j M"bl C8Jl3a1-l'bt, |
JIHIIleHbi CB060.llh.I |
.n.aTh HJJH |
He |
.naTb. 3aHBJieHie |
||||
M3B031IMKY, |
Tpe6yrom;eMy ·OT'b HaC'b |
YCJIOBJieHE.OH |
nJiaT'bl, 'llTO Mbl |
|||||
nJiaTMTb |
He |
me.naeM'b, llTO 31'0 3aBHCMT'b OT'b HarneR .ZI.06poi1: BOJIH, |
||||||
.HaM'b RameTc.H a6co.mol'HoHe)J.onycTHMIJM'b, 6escTNJIIill'M':h,HaxaJJh- H'biM'b».CJIOBOM'b, ecJIH rro O'tHorneHiro K'b MaaHy M:bl qyBcTBOBaJIM
,e6.H CB060.ZI.H:b!MH, TO no OTHOIUeHiiO K':hileTpy Ml:J CB.H3aHbl; «liaruy o6H3aHHOCTh ynJiaTHT~> eMy ro py6Jieii MIJ npn3HaeM'baaupnn.~teuuoro
3a HHM'b :K~n ':ITO-TO npio6piTeHHOe HMn ( 3apa6oTaHHOe, BblHrpaHJIOe M T. n.), TaK'b ':ITO M:bl He 'llYBCl'ByeM':hCB060JII:J OTBepRyTh OT"b
Hero nOJIOJKHTeJibH:bi-fi nOJIIOC'b HallieH 06.SI3aHHOCTH, JIMIIlH'l'hero no-
, JiylleHI.H». |
|
|
CJIOBOM'b, o6JisaHHOCTH HalUH |
6wBaiOT'b .nsyxn po.n:OB'b: B'b |
o.n.-: |
HHX'IJ CJiyqaJIX'IJ OOJI3aHHOCTb JIHUa |
C03HaeTCJI 3aupnnAe1-lHOW 3a |
opy- |
tUM:'O UJLU aa opyzuMU AU11a.Mu, <<npHHa.ZI.Jiemau~eiO .ZI.PYI:"OMY KaK'bero
.no6po (alii attributum, acquisitum)», B'b .npyrnx» CJiy':IaHx"L, o6.H-
3aHHOCTh JIHUa npe~CTaBJI.HeTC.H O.ZI.HOCTOpOHHe CBH3b1BaiOruefr, He3a- I<pinJieHHOM 3a Ki>M»-JIH6o .ZI.PYt:HM'b. B"I> 9TOM'b-TOr. lleTpa>KHUKlli
:H l3HJIM'r'bTOT'".D xapaKTepHCTHqecKiM npH3HaKn, KOTOp:biH OTJIH-
qaeT'b npaBOBI:J.H OOH3aHHOCTH OT'b HpaBCTBeHHhiX». 06JI$aHHOcTM «no - OTHOllleHiiO l\.'b .npyrHM'b CB060.llHbl.H (O.ZI.HOCTOpOHHe CB.H3biBaiOIUhr)»
OH'b CllMTaeT':h o6Jl3auuocm.JlMU upaecm6e1-l1-l'btMu; o6H3aHROCTH me «no
OTHOllleiDIO I{~ .n:pyrMM'b HeCB060.ZIHbl.fl (3aKp-f>nJieHHI:JJI aKTHBHO sa
.llpyrMMH H o6pa3yiOIUUI, TaKliM'b o6pa30M'b,.li.BYCTOpOHl-llOIO CB.H3h)»
OH'b npM3:HaeT"b
Pa3JrH•Iiro o6.H3aHHOcTe:H cooTB~TcTayer'l> pa3JIH"tJie noBeJinTeJih-