Материал: Трубецкой Е.Н.. Философия права профессора Л. И. Петражицкого
20 |
u |
" |
|
Itl:l. EBI'EHIH TPYnEIJEOH. |
|
||
Boo6me }{Oro Ohl TO Hl1 6RJIO .ZI.pyroro, KpaM-b Taro, |
«.TO nepemH- |
||
BaeT'b9TH |
ncHxl1qecKiR cocTOHHiH» |
(cTp. 21). Ec.1n1 |
6.bl TyTn mJia |
pi>'lhTOJihKO 0 HBJieHiHXp npaeooozo C03J-taUi.Jt, TO, pasyM-£eTCE 1 He 0
'leM'b6YJIO |
6hl |
11 CIIOpi:ITh: |
DO)J,'b JIBJieHiHMI1 |
rrpaBOBOrO C03HaHUI |
||||||||||
MO>KHO pa3yMi>Th BCe TO, 1JTO- .Mhl |
C03HaeM'b HJJH JJ,a.me |
80o6pa:Heae.M2J |
||||||||||||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
1 |
|
|
|
|
KaK'bnpaBo._ Ho r. IleTpa»<HUI<iii |
J1,ll;eT'b ,llaJJ~>IIIe: |
(<.l{JIH |
HaJIH'lHOCTH |
|||||||||||
npaBOBOrO HBJieru.R B'b HaiileM'bCMhiCJii»,-rOBOpHT"b OH'b,Ka1Co- |
uopM'bl |
|||||||||||||
npaea, maKo u npaeoomuotueuiJt 1), |
He |
Tpe6yeTc1l |
ae |
TOJihKO npH- |
||||||||||
3HaHiH Hame:H HOpMM, Halllero npaaa |
11JIH |
Hame:H |
OOH3aHHOCTH co |
|||||||||||
CTOpOHhi |
KOrO |
6bi TO H~ |
6nJJIO |
.ZI.pyroro, |
HO |
.n.ame cyllleCTBOBaHie |
||||||||
B'b CM~c.n-£ BfrllliHOH peaJinHOCTH, peaJibHOCTI1 |
BH'BIUHHrOMipa, Ka- |
|||||||||||||
}{OrO-JIH60 cymecTBa, KpoMi> Taro, |
KTO nepe:»umaeTn |
HOp.My npasa |
||||||||||||
HJIH npaaooTHomeHie. EcJII1, |
Harrp., |
cyeai>pHblM 11.111:1 yMaJIHmeHHbiM |
||||||||||||
·qeJIOBiiKn |
3aKJIIOqaeT'b llOrOBOp'b C"b .libHBOJIOM'b ( COH'b, rHnH03'b, |
|||||||||||||
idee fixe, |
raJIJIIO[(RHauia, |
HJJJII03iH H |
T. rr.), Harrp., 11oroaop'brrpo- |
|||||||||||
.n.am:H |
.D:YIUH, |
6paqHI:JM .llOrOBOp'b(m:eHilli1Ha, C'lHTaiOmaHceOjl Bi)I.b- |
||||||||||||
MOIO), |
TO |
3.zri»c~> |
.zri>:HcTayen |
aopMa |
opaaa, rrpe.n.rrHChiBaroma1t 11cnoJI- |
|||||||||
HeHie .nor.oaopa, cymecTEyeTb npaaooTHOmeHie, rrpaBa 11 o6HaaH-
HOCTI1, o6:r:,eKTI:J rrpaa'h11 OOH3aHHOcTe:H, .zma cyo'beKTaH T• .ZI.., xoTH
.lli>HBOJI'b,KOTOpOMY cyeatpH.biH cyO'beKT'bB'b HaiileM'bnp11MiprE npHIIHCblBaen rrpaaa H 00H3aHHOCTI11 He cymecTByeTL>, KaK'l> BHiiilHHH
' pea.llhHOCTI>» (crp.
OTcyTcTBie npasoBoro oTHOmeHiH Mem.ny Bi.zr~>MOM 11 .l(hj{BOJJOM'b,
paay.MieTC.H, He MOm:eTJ; 6h!Th .ll.OI<a3aHO He TOJibKO C'b T01JKH ap-£- gjjl TeopiH r. flerpam:H~Karo, HO M C'b TO'lKM apiHiH JII060H Hayq-
HOH Teopin, TaKn Ka.K:'b B~ 9TOH ccpepi; Hay.Ka pi>IIIHTeJII,HO HeKOM-
rreTellTHa. Ho BOT'b a-:n qelvl'b6i>11a: HHOH cyMarne.n.ruiii npe.zr.'bHBJIHeTn
Ti> |
HJIH .n.pyriH npaaoablH |
rrp11TSI3aHiH He K'b aooopamaeMhlML> HM'I:. |
|||||||
Jii>IIlMrd'b HJII1 |
HRMcpa:M'b, a |
K'b.ZI.i>HCTBHTeJibHhiM'bJIIOllHM'b~ cy:Maiile)l- |
|||||||
miM:, soo6pamaromi:H ce6a |
ncna-HCKHM'bKopoJieM'b, rrpeTeH.ZI.yeT"~> |
He |
|||||||
Ha |
aooopa}KaeMblx 'b, a |
Ha .a:-E:HcTBHTeJI~>HhlX-:n |
rro.ZI..zraHHhiX'b. ECJIH |
||||||
B3.HTb |
3a HCXO.ll.HYIO TO'lKY-reopiro r. IJeTpami1UKaro, TO pi>IIlHTeJihHO |
||||||||
HeBO~MOR<:HO |
.ZI.OKa3aTb, |
'ITO cyMaiDe.llllliM |
He |
11Mi>eT'b rrpaaa |
Ha |
||||
~· HCIIaHCKiH npeCTOJI'b. Ilp11TH3aHiH |
TaKOrO |
« HCnaHCKaro KOpOJIH» |
H~ |
||||||
npH3HaiOUH, |
KOHeq:HO, HH |
McnaHCKI1MH BJiaCTEMM, Hl1 KtML>-.111100 l13'b |
|||||||
HcnaHCKHX'".h rpam.llaHn; |
HO ll.nH |
Ha.nHl.IHOCl'H npaBOOT:H:OllieHlH, |
C'b |
||||||
TOqKH |
3pi3HiH r . IJeTp<HK.HIJ:Karo, |
TaKOe npH3HaHie BOBCe a:e Tpe~ |
|||||||
t ) KypcHa'b.-r.-toi'r.
~HJIOCO~UI fiPABA llPOcJIECCOPA JI. I. llETPA)RHIJRAf'O. |
21 |
|
6ye'rc.H.C'b .zr.pyro:H ~cTopOHhl, |
B'b npMBOllHMOM'b,npHbrkpi; ·ecTh qpa- |
|
BOBa}l HOpMa, «nepeJKHsaeMaj{» |
cyMame.zr.uniM'h H «aaKpi>nJuuomaH» - |
|
aa HHM'bOOR3aHHOCTH ero noJJ..n.aHHbJ.X"h, MHaqe roaopH,-ecTb·Ha- JIHUO sci> rl 3.11eMeHThl, KOTOpHe r. fieTpa:>KMUKiH cquraeT'b npif-
3HaKaMH npaBa, IIpasOOTHOUieHiR. 3aTpy11HeitiR,, pa3yMi>eTCR, TOJibl{O
B03pacTyT"h, eCJIH MDI |
npHMeM'hBO BHHMaHie, |
1!TO liCllaHCKie' rpam- |
|
lJ.aHe |
nepeJKMBaiOT"h HHHH HOpMH, 3aKpi3nJIHIOLlliR npaBa Ha HCITaH- |
||
CI:<ifi |
npeCTOJI'h He 3a |
yMaJIHineHHhiM'l>1 a 3a |
JJ.pyrHM'b JJHUOM'h. f JJ.i |
TOT'b KPHTepiti, Ha ocHoBaHiM KOToparo MH MorJIH Ohl pi>IIIHTh
cnOp'b Me)Klly HCITaHCKHMH |
ITOll.li.~H.HblMM |
H HX'h BOOOpamaeMbiM':b |
|||
s.nallMKOi1?. KaKHMH npH3HaKaMH Boo6me Mhi |
Mom:ebt'h OTJIH1lHTo |
||||
.ZI.'BHCTBHTeJJhHOe npaBO on npaBOBOrO |
y6iJK){eHiJI · HJIH |
raJI.TIIOI.{H- |
|||
HaUiH 1)? |
|
|
|
|
|
3MnHpHtzeCKaH IICHXOJIOriSI |
6e3CH.lihHa |
.ztaT~ |
TOT'b H.TIH |
J.llpyroif |
|
OTiliT'b Ha 9TOT'bBOIIpOc'n, a DOTOMy, |
ecJIH MLI |
cTaHeM"h Ha TO'IKY |
|||
apiHiH r. DeTpa)IHIUKaro, To |
HaM':h npHlleTCH npHaHaTb HepaapimH- |
||||
M~MH ~ci; T~ npasoBRe crropu, r.zr.1 o?~ cTopoHDI OAHHruKoso y6i- >KJJ.eHH B'hnpaBOT'BCBOero 11-BJia: o6i CITOpHII.J.iH CTOpOHhl OJJ.HA:aKOBO nepe>KHBaiOT'L npaBOBbiJI HOpMH, 3aKpi>n.nHIOIIliH sa HHMH Ty HJIH
.zr.pyryro ~nopHyro semh H.nM o6HsaTeJILCTBo; no TeopiH r. IIe-fpa- mnuKaro B'h sTOM'b yoi>JK.zr.eHiM M aaKJiroqaeTc}l. cymHocTh npasa;
1) f. lleTpa)l{HUKili, MOJKen .6-biTb, CKa)KCTn, q1'0 cy6'heK'JOM1>· npa:aa Bn npRBe,neHHOMn npHM'spi>RBJUieTOI ne IWHKpeTHoe JJim;o-y.MaJIHmeHH'LIRMBaH'l>lleT-
poBn, Boo6pa)Karoruii1 ce6.H KopoJieM'b,a. H.neaJIJ:.HOe JIHUO-e<J.\OpO.ijL)}, Kai\.'1>n.zLea (no llOBO.UY cmpaBOOTHOWeHiRn :Me:>K.II.Y .lLBYMH Jii>IIIIThlH OH"b .D,'BRCTBHT~Ji'LHO rOBO-
pnTn, qTo cy6"beKTOM'b npaBa RBJUieTCR B.Ui>Ch He ,D;B:fiCTBIITeJILHhlR 'leJIOBi>K1>,
B006pa)KaiOruin ceoJI Jii>IIIHMn, .a azr.eaJihHoe JJHUO-Jli>miii). Bp.H.ir.n JIH O.D.HaKO I1
Tal{oe ToJIKonanfe -noMO:>KeTl> r. IIerpamnui\oMy crrpa.snTLCR c» nepaspi>IIIHMhlMB
.li.Jifl ero TeopiH aaTpfJI.HeHiHMH. Bo-nepBLIX'L;OHO pi>mHTeJILHO He oyJI.eT'L co01'Bi>'rCT:BOBaThnpaBOC03HaiDIO cyMaWe.zLmaro, KOTOphl·R y61i:>KlleHn B"b• TOM"b, qTQ
. He KaKOH-.rm6o H~eanHI:.Ifi <<:KOpOJI'b)), a HMeHHO OHn.l IfBaHn TleTpOB'h,TOT'b sa-
KOHHhlH RcnaacKiii BJia.zr.I>IKa, K01'opoMy o6nsam,z noBHH9Ban.cn J!..Cnaauhl. Bo-
B1'0PLIXn,ecm cTa1'haa ::ny Toq}(y aptain, TO cnop1:. Mem.uy llBaHOM"b
BLIM"L H HcnaHCKHMH rpam.naHaMII CTaaeT'b eme oorle H~pa3ptiiiHMhlM1>: H60 <ror.na MLI 6y,ne.Mn BLIRy~K.ZLeHhl npHMi>HR1''b'tOT'Lme KpHTepifi Kn npaBOCOSBaHiBJ HCfiaHue:an n, CJii>l[OBaTeJILHO, npmman,, liTO .ntHCTBHTeJILHbiM'L IIX'll BJiaJILIKOBJ
HBJIHeTC.H ae l\aKOe·JIH60KOHKpeTHOe .MCTopnlleCKOe JIJ.III.O, a C<IWpOJih, KaKl> JI.:Zie.H1>·
EcJIH TaKn, 'ToIJa KaKHXn ocaoBaHiRX'll cJii>JI.ye1'1> npe.n.noqecTI> npaBy HnaHa
lleTpoBa npaBo KaKoro·H.H6y.Uh AJILcf>oHca_ 1iJII1 ci>ep.lll·iHaRlia? 1\aKHMn cnoco6oM'L Mhl MO>ReMn BLTBeCTII ·HB'LrrpaBOOTHOilleHifi Me:IK.ZI.Y H.UeaJihHhl:MH JIH~alii.H RaRUl· JIH6o npaBa H o6naaHHOCTH nJIR
